The Right Way to Do Congressional Oversight

3 hours ago 5

Rommie Analytics

Congressional oversight matters. Here, Barney Frank, then chair of the House Financial Services Committee, grills a witness as the panel probes the financial crisis.

The November midterm election results taught us a lot. Exit polling shows Americans are fed up with the corruption and self-dealing by President Trump, his administration, and his allies. In fact, 90 percent of voters surveyed in an NBC exit poll identified corruption as a “crucial or significant factor” in their votes. The cost of living, the brutal immigration crackdowns, and concerns about AI also loomed large in the minds of voters. And the American people aren’t only upset with this administration; they’re upset with the current Congress as well. Importantly, a majority of Americans polled disapproved of the job Congress has been doing. Voters clearly want elected leaders to tackle affordability, but they also want a legislative branch that checks the Trump administration’s abuses and corruption. The incoming Congress should provide Americans with the accountability they demand. Here are three things Congress can consider as it approaches the task.

Be Bold and Broad in Conducting Oversight

The Supreme Court has recognized that Congress’s broad power to investigate is “co-extensive with its power to legislate.” Congress cannot legislate wisely without good information, and when it lacks it, it must obtain it from other sources, including the executive branch.

The Trump administration will almost certainly resist accountability, but that should not deter Congress from exercising its oversight duty. Congress should investigate issues that require investigation, full stop. It should expect pushback and plan accordingly. This means not only considering criminal enforcement of subpoenas, but also anticipating resistance to such criminal referrals by a Department of Justice headed by Todd Blanche, President Trump’s former personal criminal defense lawyer. Committee leadership should be prepared to move promptly for civil enforcement of its subpoenas in federal court when parties refuse to testify or provide requested information. And Congress can and should ask the courts for expedited consideration to prevent the administration from running out the clock, as it tried to do during Trump’s first term.

Breadth will be important as well. For instance, if investigating how no-bid contracts led to the botched restoration of the Lincoln Reflecting Pool, and why taxpayers ended up footing the $14.7 million bill, it will be important not only to request testimony and information from executive branch officials, but also from the private companies and non-governmental actors involved. A broad approach acts as a safeguard. Courts can move quickly, but sometimes they don’t. If litigation to enforce subpoenas against executive branch sources proceeds too slowly, private companies and non-governmental actors can at least provide the other half of the communications that led to the Reflecting Pool fiasco. Remember that the Supreme Court recently reaffirmed Congress’s power to investigate the executive branch—including the president—and acknowledged that such investigations can involve information held by private third parties. Oversight requests to private corporations have historically yielded rich information that supported strong investigations. For example, congressional investigations of banking industry abuses that led to the 2008 financial crisis informed the crafting and passage of the Dodd-Frank Wall Street Reform and Consumer Protection Act. More recently, investigations and hearings involving social media companies informed the drafting and introduction of multiple bills aimed at strengthening protections for children.

Use All The Tools In The Toolbox

If Congress finds it is being thwarted by an administration trying to run out the clock on oversight requests, it can create an expedited pathway for federal courts to review oversight disputes. In the past, Republicans and Democrats alike have proposed such a judicial fast track. Congress can also use its power of the purse when faced with stonewalling. For example, if Congress does not get prompt answers about the atrocious killings by ICE and CBP agents, or the federal government’s continuing failure to cooperate with state and local officials to investigate this violence properly, it should make its Department of Homeland Security appropriations decisions accordingly. And this does not simply apply to future appropriations. Congress can also rescind appropriations.

Understand the Power of Narrative

As Congress performs oversight on behalf of the American people, it should remember the importance of narrative. Americans must understand that these investigations are about accountability and making things better for them, not about political retribution. Hearings can help Congress explain. But given a limited legislative calendar—and the reality that most busy Americans don’t follow congressional hearings closely—clear, well-structured hearings with strong witnesses will be necessary, but not sufficient. Congressional leaders should proactively communicate the connections between the problems they are investigating and the very real pain points in people’s lives. Some leaders and committees have already begun to do this, producing materials that explain the costs of unchecked corruption and self-dealing, with glaring examples of how these abuses have led to higher prices and fewer protections for everyday Americans. Finally, in our fractured, siloed media landscape, congressional leaders need to use the full array of new media and enlist interested content creators to get their message out as widely as possible. Even a clear narrative will be of little value if it doesn’t reach its audience.

The American people spoke at the ballot box. They want Congress to provide a check against Trump administration abuses that are making their lives more difficult and less secure. The Constitution provides the legislative branch with broad oversight powers, and the incoming Congress should use them.

The post The Right Way to Do Congressional Oversight appeared first on Washington Monthly.

Read Entire Article